Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Meaning Meeting - Matthew Ganquan Shi / Restricting the semantics of interrogative disjunctors

A young man wearing a baseball cap, sitting in a conference audience.

Meaning Meeting - Matthew Ganquan Shi / Restricting the semantics of interrogative disjunctors

Linguistics | Philosophy Wednesday, November 18, 2026 3:30 pm - 4:45 pm Marie Mount Hall, 1108B

Wednesday November 18, Matthew shares his work on a Mandarin morpheme, 還是, that forms Alternative Questions, which he will present at the Amsterdam Colloquium next month. The title is "Restricting the semantics of interrogative disjunctors."


In this presentation, I will propose an asymmetric analysis of alternative questions formed by an interrogative disjunctor háishì in Mandarin Chinese.

The target surface configuration is [S_L háishì S_R]?

Starting with initial screening of the data, we observe a robust asymmetry between S_L and S_R: while S_R consistently shows propositional properties, S_L sometimes shows question properties. Thus, I hypothesize that háishì(p) maps from a question to an augmented question, with p added to its Hamblin set.

The analysis is supported by the fact that when S_L and S_R are allegedly in separate sentences, Q1: [ S_L ]? Q2: [ e háishì S_R ]?, the empty argument e for háishì cannot be a propositional.

I will extend the asymmetric analysis to account for basic data where S_L doesn’t have overt interrogative syntax, and argue that those cases can be analyzed as involving covert interrogative syntax and thus are compatible with the current proposal.

Possible caveats. (a) Clause-medial reduced háishì cases: whether we need to assume ellipsis or type-flexible analysis will be discussed, given the potential counterexamples against the ellipsis analysis discussed in Erlewine (2025). (b) There are several contrasting behaviors between full-fledged CP disjunctions and those reduced ones when S_L is a wh-question or a biased question. I don’t have a concrete answer at this moment, so I will try to make speculations here and welcome discussion and feedback.
 

Add to Calendar 11/18/26 15:30:00 11/18/26 16:45:00 America/New_York Meaning Meeting - Matthew Ganquan Shi / Restricting the semantics of interrogative disjunctors

Wednesday November 18, Matthew shares his work on a Mandarin morpheme, 還是, that forms Alternative Questions, which he will present at the Amsterdam Colloquium next month. The title is "Restricting the semantics of interrogative disjunctors."


In this presentation, I will propose an asymmetric analysis of alternative questions formed by an interrogative disjunctor háishì in Mandarin Chinese.

The target surface configuration is [S_L háishì S_R]?

Starting with initial screening of the data, we observe a robust asymmetry between S_L and S_R: while S_R consistently shows propositional properties, S_L sometimes shows question properties. Thus, I hypothesize that háishì(p) maps from a question to an augmented question, with p added to its Hamblin set.

The analysis is supported by the fact that when S_L and S_R are allegedly in separate sentences, Q1: [ S_L ]? Q2: [ e háishì S_R ]?, the empty argument e for háishì cannot be a propositional.

I will extend the asymmetric analysis to account for basic data where S_L doesn’t have overt interrogative syntax, and argue that those cases can be analyzed as involving covert interrogative syntax and thus are compatible with the current proposal.

Possible caveats. (a) Clause-medial reduced háishì cases: whether we need to assume ellipsis or type-flexible analysis will be discussed, given the potential counterexamples against the ellipsis analysis discussed in Erlewine (2025). (b) There are several contrasting behaviors between full-fledged CP disjunctions and those reduced ones when S_L is a wh-question or a biased question. I don’t have a concrete answer at this moment, so I will try to make speculations here and welcome discussion and feedback.
 

Marie Mount Hall false